Delicious Chicken Pot Pie Recipe…No, Seriously…

Jump to recipe

Delicious Chicken Pot Pie Recipe…No, Seriously…

I’m going to let you in on a delicious chicken pot pie recipe that you’ll come back to again and again when you’re in the mood for comfort food! No, seriously…chicken pot pie can be delicious! Not only that, it can be easy without being ready-made and stocked in your freezer!

Chicken Pot Pie Nostalgia

Who else grew up on these things?

chicken pot pie recipe

Honestly, I liked a good ol’ frozen chicken pot pie every now and then as a kid. What is it about growing up that makes things like that not taste as good?  I guess it comes with having a more sophisticated palate.  I’m not a big fan of Hot Pockets or frozen pizza, either, and I used to think we had hit pay dirt when something like that showed up in the freezer!

Now that I have more refined taste (and a hefty set of hips to maintain), I like to make things from scratch. I like to make things from scratch without killing myself, to be correct.  This chicken pot pie recipe is so perfect, because it’s not difficult, it doesn’t use 80-million ingredients, and it’s really, really delicious.

Chicken Pot Pie Recipe

It’s a chicken pot pie recipe I found online and embellished it a little.  The original recipe is called Angela’s Amazing Chicken Pot Pie, and it’s on  Someone came along later and added a photo that looks like a yummy, veggie-filled pot pie, but the recipe itself is pretty boring.  Chicken and potatoes.  White, bland, blah. The chicken pot pie filling should definitely be more colorful and exciting than that, but it’s the crust that makes this recipe so yummy, and easy. I’m telling you, this is the best chicken pot pie out there, if you make the changes I made.

Here’s what I did differently:

  • I used boneless, skinless chicken breasts instead of thighs. I’m a white-meat girl.
  • I cooked my chicken in water, but added an onion, a couple of stalks of celery, and a few carrots for flavor. Plus seasoning. Like salt, pepper, and garlic powder.  Chicken needs more than water to taste scrumptious.
  • I used frozen hash brown potatoes instead of peeling and dicing potatoes. This is a huge time-saver, and I’ve shared that little secret before.
  • I added some frozen peas to my boiling pot of yumminess in the last 5 minutes of cooking time.
  • I used the same carrots and celery that I cooked with my chicken in the pot pie itself.  Just let your veggies cool and little, and they’re easy to cut up.chicken pot pie recipe

Here’s what I did wrong:

This recipe for chicken pot pie is really fool-proof. The crust is so simple: milk, butter and self-rising flour.

chicken pot pie recipe

Follow the directions, and make sure you let the milk/butter mixture cool. I did that, so that wasn’t my mistake. I had two bags of self-rising flour in my pantry.

crust batter

I grabbed one, and it turns out, is was very close to it’s “fresh by” date.  It didn’t rise as much as I would’ve liked.  Also, I have this lovely, wonderful, beautiful gas stove (I don’t dare call it the names I’m really thinking, lest it quit on me) that doesn’t brown anything except on the bottom.

chicken pot pie recipe

Honestly, I flubbed it up on purpose. I mean, you don’t think I really messed up the easiest chicken pot pie crust in the world, right? That way, when you make it, yours will turn out fluffy and golden brown, and you’ll be all puffed up thinking you’re a better cook than me!  I’m so generous.

No matter about the flat-ish, golden-without-the-brown crust…this was so delicious.

chicken pot pie recipe

It is perfect for a cold night, and your kids will love it!  Trust me, if Tigger loved it, and she did, your kids will love love it.  She’s my picky one, and she had seconds.

Annoying Reviewers

Do you visit  I’ve been going to that site for years, and I have my own little favorites in my recipe box. There are tons of great recipes on the site, and some that are kind of “meh”.  What kills me are the reviews!  I don’t mean to encourage anyone to waste time, but if you scan through a few recipes and reviews, you’ll see what I mean.  Say there’s a recipe for beef burritos. The first review might be “Delicious!  Thanks for sharing!”  Ok, that’s nice.  Then you’ll see something like, “This was good, except I used chicken instead of beef, and we made it nachos instead of burritos.  I used 1/2 cup of beef stock instead of a whole cup, 2 peppers instead of 1, and we don’t like cheese so we left that out.  I also added wine, cherries, and some anchovy paste. Otherwise, it was great!”

Seriously?  You changed EVERYTHING; so just write your own dang recipe!  Gah!  Yes, I added some things to this chicken pot pie recipe, but it’s still the same basic recipe, just with some embellishments.  I have been known to get caught up in the ridiculous reviews for an undisclosed amount of time, shaking my head at people’s weirdness.  It’s kind of like Facebook drama…you don’t want to read it, but sometimes you just can’t turn away.

Anywho…I do hope you’ll try this chicken pot pie recipe, and I hope you and your family get warmed down to your toes from eating it! I’d love it if you found this to be the best chicken pot pie ever…it’s definitely way better than the frozen stuff!

chicken pot pie recipe

Happy cooking!

X,O,X,O,   Martie

This post is linked up with Thursday Favorite Things!